Making Lemonade: Why Museums and Galleries Deaccession Artworks
When you think about a museum or art gallery collection, you might imagine that once an artwork becomes part of the collection, it stays there forever.
In reality, museum collections are living, changing things. As a gallery grows, its collecting priorities change, our understanding of the collection develops, and the needs of the community evolve. Sometimes, an artwork that was appropriate for the collection at one point may no longer be the right fit.
This is where deaccessioning comes in.
At the Mann Art Gallery, deaccessioning is not about getting rid of artworks we no longer like. It is a careful collections-management process that helps us ensure that the Permanent Collection remains relevant, well cared for, responsibly documented, and meaningful to the communities we serve.
Think of it as making lemonade out of lemons: sometimes a change or challenge gives us an opportunity to make the collection stronger.
What is deaccessioning?

Deaccessioning is the formal process of removing an artwork from a museum or gallery’s Permanent Collection.
It is important to understand that deaccessioning is not the same thing as throwing something away. It is a considered decision that involves reviewing an artwork’s history, ownership, condition, significance, relevance to the collection, and potential future use.
The Mann Art Gallery’s updated Collections Policy provides a framework for making these decisions responsibly and consistently.
A collection is held in trust for the public. This means that we have a responsibility to care for the objects entrusted to us and to make decisions that support the long-term health and purpose of the collection.
Why would a museum deaccession an artwork?
There are many legitimate reasons an artwork may be considered for deaccessioning.
For example, an artwork may:
no longer fit within the Gallery’s collecting mandate or current collection priorities;
be very similar to other works already represented in the collection;
lack sufficient documentation or provenance;
be incomplete or no longer represent the significance for which it was originally acquired;
require conservation or storage resources that the Gallery cannot reasonably provide;
have limited potential for exhibition, research, education, or community use; or
have become better suited to another institution or collection.
was inappropriately or accidentally acquired
These decisions are not made because an artwork is considered “bad” or unimportant. An artwork can be valuable, historically interesting, or artistically significant and still not be the right fit for a particular collection.
A museum's responsibility is not simply to collect as much as possible. It is to build and care for a collection that has a clear purpose.
Why does the Mann Art Gallery need to do this?
The Mann Art Gallery's Permanent Collection has grown significantly over the years, with over 4,000 artworks. With growth comes responsibility.
Every artwork requires appropriate storage, documentation, environmental monitoring, handling, conservation planning, staff time, and sometimes specialized materials or equipment. Gallery space and resources are not unlimited.
At the same time, our understanding of what a strong and representative collection looks like continues to develop.
The Mann Art Gallery's updated Collections Policy helps us look critically at what we already have and consider what we want the collection to represent in the future.
This can mean identifying gaps in the collection and seeking opportunities to acquire works that better reflect the diversity of artists, communities, perspectives, and experiences that make up Prince Albert and Saskatchewan.
It can also mean recognizing when we have works that are no longer the best fit for our mandate.
Deaccessioning creates an opportunity to redirect limited resources toward the care and development of the collection as a whole.
In other words, sometimes making the collection stronger means making thoughtful decisions about what belongs in it.
Does deaccessioning mean an artwork will be thrown away?
Not usually.
One of the most important principles of responsible deaccessioning is that an artwork should be kept within the public or cultural sphere whenever possible.
The Museum Association of Saskatchewan (MAS) explains that, once an institution has established legal ownership and formally approved a deaccession, museums should prioritize keeping deaccessioned artifacts within the public domain.
The first option may be to contact another gallery, museum or cultural institution to see whether the artwork would be a better fit for its collection. In some circumstances, a transfer or exchange may be possible.
Other options may include a carefully managed sale, with proceeds directed back toward collection-related needs, depending on the Gallery's policies and applicable requirements.
Destruction is generally considered only as a last resort, such as when an object is severely deteriorated.
For sacred or culturally sensitive materials, additional considerations and consultation are required.
What about the person who originally donated the artwork?
This is one reason documentation and legal ownership are so important.
Before an artwork can be deaccessioned, the Gallery must establish that it has legal title to the work. A signed gift agreement or transfer of ownership documentation is an important part of establishing that ownership.
As MAS explains in its resource Deaccessioning Artifacts from Your Collection, museums cannot simply deaccession an object when ownership is uncertain. This is particularly important for works that were donated, transferred, or placed with a museum under unclear arrangements.
This is one of the reasons why strong collections documentation matters so much.
Every artwork in a museum's collection should have a clear record of its history, ownership, location, condition, and relationship to the institution.
What happens during the deaccessioning process?
Deaccessioning is not a single decision made by one person.
A proposed deaccession should go through the Gallery's established collections-management process. This includes reviewing the artwork and its documentation, identifying the reason for the proposed deaccession, considering its significance and potential future use, confirming legal ownership, and obtaining the appropriate institutional board approvals.
The decision and the reasons behind it are documented as part of the artwork's permanent records.
Once an artwork has formally been deaccessioned, the Gallery must also document what happens to it afterward.
This creates an important paper trail from the original decision to deaccession through to the final method of disposal or transfer.
Why not just keep everything?
It can seem like keeping everything would be the safest option.
But galleries and museums have finite resources.
Every object takes up physical space. Every object requires documentation and care. Some objects require significant conservation resources, specialized storage, or environmental controls. When a collection grows without a clear strategy, it can become increasingly difficult to care properly for everything within it.
A collection that contains everything may ultimately be less useful than a collection that has been thoughtfully developed around a clear purpose.
Responsible deaccessioning allows galleries and museums to ask important questions:
What should we preserve? Why should we preserve it? Who does it serve? And how can we care for it responsibly?
These questions help ensure that the Permanent Collection remains a meaningful resource for future generations.
Making lemonade out of lemons
Changes to a collection can sometimes feel uncomfortable.

The Mann Art Gallery recognizes that artworks can carry personal histories and memories for artists, donors, families, and community members. Deaccessioning therefore requires care, respect, transparency, and thoughtful decision-making.
But change can also create opportunities.
When an artwork is no longer the right fit for the Mann Art Gallery, finding a more appropriate home for it may allow another institution or community to benefit from it. Redirecting limited resources can allow the Gallery to better care for the works that remain. And reviewing the collection can help us identify where there are gaps and where future acquisitions can make the collection more representative and meaningful.
That is the “lemonade.”
Deaccessioning is not about making the collection smaller for the sake of making it smaller. It is about making thoughtful choices so that the collection can continue to grow, evolve, and serve the community well.
Learning More
The Mann Art Gallery is committed to responsible collections management and to being transparent about the work that goes into caring for the Permanent Collection.
For readers interested in learning more about deaccessioning, we recommend the Museum Association of Saskatchewan's resource:
Chris Selman and Kathleen Watkin, “Deaccessioning Artifacts from Your Collection: A Museum’s Rights and Deaccessioning the Collection.”
The resource provides an accessible overview of why museums deaccession objects, the importance of establishing legal ownership, approval processes, disposal priorities, and documentation requirements.
The resource also points readers toward additional collections-management resources, including the Collections Documentation Manual for Saskatchewan Museums and the Standards for Saskatchewan Museums.
A Note on Transparency
Deaccessioning is a normal and responsible part of museum collections management. While not every detail of an individual collections decision may be appropriate for public disclosure, particularly where privacy, donor information, cultural sensitivity, or legal matters are involved,
the Mann Art Gallery believes that helping our community understand why museums make these decisions is an important part of our role as a public institution.
Our collection belongs to the broader story of Prince Albert, Saskatchewan, and the communities we serve. Caring for that collection means not only preserving objects, but continually considering how we can make the collection more relevant, accessible, representative, and sustainable for the future.
%20white%20b.png)

Comments